New Study Shows Media Lied About Covid-19

In following various news reports on the Covid-19 pandemic, Dartmouth Economic Professor Bruce Sacerdote came to believe that the reporting was not consistent with his understanding of the scientific data.  He sensed that the media played up the bad news and played down good news. This is something upon which I have been commenting for most of the past year. Has the media lied about Covid-19?

Unlike me, Sacerdote had the professional means to put his suspicion to the test.  He gathered a few colleagues and together they built a database of the major news networks and hundreds of publications throughout the United States and abroad.  Like all good professionals, Sacerdote and colleagues provided their findings to the National Bureau of Economic Research. It then published them as a working paper entitled “Why is all Covid-19 news bad news?”

And what did they find?  Voilà!  Sacerdote was correct.

News reports hyped bad news and disregarded more positive developments.  It was not even close. He found that the major news outlets with a national audience – including such newspapers as the New York Times and the Washington Post – were the most one-sided and negative.  No surprise there.

In fact, Molly Cook, a co-author of the study said, “The most well-read U.S. media are outliers in terms of their negativity.”  That means the Times and Post were waaaaay more negative than other, less prominent, publications.

Another co-author, Ranjan Sehgal, said, “The media is painting a picture that is a little bit different from what the scientists are saying.” (Do I get another “I told you so?”)

They found that 87 percent of the pandemic coverage in the national media was negative.  That compared to 51 percent negative in international news, 53 percent in U.S. local media and 64 percent in scientific journals.

So, why are the major news outlets not giving us fair and balanced reports?

Sacerdote and his team confess that they do not know, but maybe … just maybe … the news folks are giving people what they want.  In an article in the New York Times, Sacerdote seemed to be letting the news media off the hook.

“Human beings, particularly consumers of major media, like negativity in their stories.  We think the major media are responding to consumer demand,” he said.  That goes along with the old news media adage, “If it bleeds, it leads.”

But if that were true, why is it only the very liberal national media that so skews to negativity? Don’t local news outlets need to appeal to the same audiences?  Also, if that is what we the people want, why do we hold the national news media in such low regard? Why do we have such a distrust of Fourth Estate’s veracity — according to polls.

And what about the international media, which has only a 51 percent negativity rating – half negative, half positive?

In addressing that point Sacerdote makes a verrrrry interesting observation.  He speculates that perhaps it is because they — such outlets as Britain’s BBC – receive government funding “potentially making them less focused on consumer demand.”  Ponder that for a moment.  Government funding makes the news services “less focus on consumer demand.”

Then who does government-funded media focus on?  If your first guess is THE GOVERNMENT, you can give yourself a pat on the back.  Think about that next time you tune into PBS.

Unfortunately, the report by Sacerdote fails to answer – or even ask – the most significant question.  Was all this negativism driven by the political biases of the news outlets?  There is no argument that virtually every negative story regarding Covid-19 served as the opening for a criticism of President Trump, Republicans and conservatives.

Also, what would a similar analysis show since the inauguration of President Biden?

I am betting that an empirical statistical analysis would show the reversal in the reporting by the national media from predominantly negative to predominantly positive.  After all, everything about the Biden administration is given glowing reviews.

Sacerdote was reluctant to say that the media lied about Covid-19 or had been misleading us intentionally – just a matter of only telling one side of the story.  He should be reminded that half of a truth is a lie.

The fellow who wrote a New York Times piece on the report, David Leonhardt, gave his own spin. He said that since the politicians and others always offer the positive side of a story from their perspective, it is necessary for the media to fill in the other side.

No, it is not, David.  That is the job of folks on the other side of the issue.  And it is your ethical responsibility to present BOTH sides.  You are not supposed to cancel, censor or delete positive news or use your platform to proffer for one side.  That is prosecutorial propaganda.

I guess in the final analysis, Sacerdote and his colleagues have merely confirmed what virtually every American can see every day.  To put it kindly … today’s major media lied about Covid-19 and is untrustworthy as a reliable source of information.

So, there tis.

3 Comments on this post.
  • Elizabeth Estrada aka CHIAKIA
    27 March 2021 at 7:46 pm
    Leave a Reply


  • Bill Turney
    27 March 2021 at 7:53 pm
    Leave a Reply

    If you get your news solely from the liberal fake news media, you are doing yourself a great disservice.

  • Mustangusn04
    27 March 2021 at 8:10 pm
    Leave a Reply

    Anyone that takes the msn as gospel are lemmings.

  • Leave a Reply

    • The Biden Border Wall April 9, 2021
      Believe it or not, Biden Administration officials are thinking about resuming border wall construction along the US-Mexico border. “I think it’s great that they reversed themselves, but a lot of damage was done because we were gonna have that wall almost complete. You know, it delayed two and a half years because of lawsuits,” said […]
    • Biden’s New Executive Orders on Gun Control April 9, 2021
      President Biden announced six executive orders that aim to address what he calls the ongoing "gun violence public health epidemic" in America. One of the incoming actions will be regulation of "ghost guns" — makeshift weapons that can be assembled at home or ones without a serial number. Biden's executive orders come almost 80 days […]
    • Will Andrew Giuliani Replace Andrew Cuomo? April 9, 2021
      Andrew Giuliani, a former top aide to President Donald Trump and the son of former New York City Mayor Rudy Giuliani, is "heavily considering" running for governor of New York against current governor Andrew Cuomo in 2022. "I plan to run," the 35-year-old said, adding that "outside of anybody named Trump," he thinks he has […]
    • Violent Axe-wielding Antifa Protester Arrested and Released Twice April 8, 2021
      Rangers from the Portland Parks and Recreation department were threatened by an Antifa protester carrying an axe and a paintball gun in downtown Portland. The man initially assaulted a bicyclist. He was arrested for multiple violent crimes, released, and then arrested again within 48 hours. Randy Allen Graves, 32, is facing numerous felonies and over […]
    • Biden Administration Stops Construction of “Racist” Highway April 6, 2021
      The Biden administration is pausing the construction of a major highway expansion in Houston, Texas, claiming that the project is racist and harmful to the environment. The project, which has been years in the making, was going to widen certain sections of Interstate 45. But the Department of Transportation invoked the Civil Rights Act of […]
    • Should You Boycott Delta Airlines? April 5, 2021
      I cannot participate in a boycott of Delta Airlines for becoming too political – in opposition to my views, of course.  That is because I avoid flying Delta like a plague – more than the current pandemic, in fact.  My avoidance is not political.  It is based on two factors – service and safety. I […]
    • Biden Turning Out to be the Liar-in-Chief April 5, 2021
      President Biden has never had a reputation for personal integrity. His history is marked with serious accusations of plagiarism – one so serious that he had to drop out of the 1987 presidential campaign. He has told audacious lies about his schooling. Biden claimed to be in the top quarter of his law class when […]
    • Why The Left Is Now Canceling Obama April 2, 2021
      Barack and Michelle Obama are the latest victims of cancel culture. Latino activists in the suburbs of Chicago are protesting the renaming of a local middle school after the 44th president of the United States because of his immigration policies. The issue was brought up earlier this week at a meeting at the Waukegan, Illinois […]
    • George Floyd’s Girlfriend Testifies That He Overdosed Months Before Death, Was With Drug Dealer During Arrest April 2, 2021
      George Floyd’s girlfriend, Courteney Ross, discussed her deceased partner's history of drug abuse and battle with addiction in court on Thursday. Ross testified about how she met Floyd and their shared struggle with addiction and drug abuse. Her testimony comes as former Minneapolis Police Officer Derek Chauvin is on trial for second-degree murder, third-degree murder, […]
    • Why Nursing Home Staff Are Not Getting Vaccinated April 1, 2021
      Up to 50% of nursing home staff in the United States have not received the COVID vaccine despite a federal pharmacy partnership that delivered roughly 8 million doses to more than 63,000 nursing homes and other long-term-care facilities.  In states like Arkansas, West Virginia, and South Dakota, that percentage falls to less than 33%. “We […]